Tampilkan postingan dengan label high protein diet. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label high protein diet. Tampilkan semua postingan

Kamis, 26 Mei 2016

Protein Oxidation 101: 8 Simple Rules to Minimize PROTOX and Maximize the Proven Benefits of High(er) Protein Diets

You're not going to like it, but not all of the protein foods in this photo deserve the attribute "SuppVersity Suggested"
I usually try to keep my promises,... even if this means hours of research and ending up with the conclusion that "more research is necessary"... and no, you don't have to worry, there's more than that in the following ~4500 words + 45 references (not including those I didn't copy from the reviews I cite): plenty of information about the effects of cooking, storage, temperature changes, physical processing, and - you're lucky - a preliminary list of 8 tips / rules (and short explanations) that will help you minimize the amount of oxidized protein in your diet, without having to cut back on the intake of your beloved protein ;-)

For those of you who are now wondering PROTOX is / are and why they are (literally) a matter of life or death, I suggest you go back to my previous article about the (ill) health effects of oxidized dietary (!) proteins from Thursday, May 19, 2016 (read the article | as always, for free!).
This is not an anti-high-protein article. It is one arguing in favor of "treating your protein right"

Are You Protein Wheysting?

5x More Than the FDA Allows!

More Protein ≠ More Satiety

Protein Oxidation = Health Threat

Protein Timing DOES Matter!

More Protein = More Liver Fat?
In view of the fact that this article got longer than the average "101" article, I'd suggest that anyone who is in a hurry fast forward to the list of eight simple rules I announced in the title of this article. You can bookmark the rest for later, print it to read it in bed or simply rely on my interpretation of the implications of what we know about the various ways processing and storage can damage proteins :
  • Cooking, frying, baking, i.e. heat treatment(s), in general - While you don't have to eat your meat, fish and dairy raw, those of you who "fry their proteins to death" and eat their steak well-done are at a higher risk of exposing themselves to exuberant amounts of oxidized proteins than the rare steak conconnoisseurs.

    While the number of studies testing for protein oxidation in meats during cooking is higher than those on any other protein source, their number is, compared to the one of studies investigating the oxidation of fats and cholesterol in meat products, still low and their significance is crippled by the use of either inappropriate markers of protein oxidation or different markers that make it virtually impossible to compare the results of one study to another.

    An example of the initially mentioned problem, i.e. the use of inappropriate markers of protein oxidation, would be the 1997 study on the effects of different cooking methods on some lipid and protein components of hamburgers by Rodriguez-Estrada, M. T., et al. (1997). Their use of free form amino acids as marker of protein oxidation suffers from the presence of the latter in raw meat and their drip loss during cooking.
    Figure 1: In contrast to the amount of free amino acids, the formation of Schiff bases provides reliable information about the oxidation of protein during e.g. cooking (data from Gatellier. 2010).
    A much better way to estimate the degree of protein oxidation in meat and other high protein foods is the formation / presence of Schiff bases. The latter are precursors to maillard products of which studies indicate that they have divergent effects on human health: with some of them being implicated in the development of diabetes mellitus, cardiovascular complications, and Alzheimer's disease and others ostensibly helping with gut health, inflammation, and chemoprevention (the benefits appear to be mediated by hormesis or the effect of these molecules on the make-up of your microbiome | Smith. 1994; Somoza. 2005; Tuohy. 2006; Tessier. 2012). Measuring these byproducts of reactions between proteins and aldehydic products, as it was done by Gatellier, et al. (2010 | see data in Figure 1), provides significantly more reliable information about the degree of protein oxidation in foods than the measurement of the amount of free amino acids which would suggest that raw meat was more oxidized than cooked meat (cf. Rodriguez-Estrada. 1997), because the drip loss of amino acids is falsely interpreted as a reduction in protein oxidation compared to the raw product. That this is not the case and heating meat and other high protein foods will increase, not decrease the amount of oxidized proteins can be seen in the data from Gatellier, et al. in Figure 1.

    Furthermore, Gatellier's and other studies indicate that the formation of protein oxides which starts at relatively low temperatures of only >65°C does not begin to really take off before temperatures of 123-207°C - temperatures as you would see them if you fry your foods and can be reduced (albeit not significantly | 1300% increase vs 3500% increase | cf. Figure 2) if the cattle has been fed anti-oxidant rich diets.
    Figure 2: Effect of diet and cooking parameters on protein oxidative modifications (Gatellier. 2010).
    This is not surprising, as it has long been established that increases in lipoxidation products go hand in hand with increased oxidative damage to proteins (Requena. 1996). Any diet that would modify the concentration of certain lipids and lipid protecting antioxidants (like vitamin E) will thus change both, the oxidation of fats and proteins in high protein foods. The reverse applies to pro-oxidant diets (e.g. with rancid oils), like the one Zhang et al. (2010) used in broiler chickens whose breast meat would then show increased levels of oxidized proteins.

    You must not forget, however, that the data in Figure 1 also shows that even the quality L+R meat is not fully protected from oxidation when it is heated at high(er) temperatures for more than 60 seconds - and that's something that is going to happen even for the most bloody (non-raw) steak. "t "and "T", i.e. time and temperature, are thus not the only, but the most significant determinants of  protein oxidative modifications (cf. Figure 3).
An increased drip loss suggest increased protein oxidation: It's not just annoying if your meat weights only half of what it weighed before cooking, it is also an albeit not 100% reliable indicator or, I should say, correlate of increased protein oxidation. That's at least what a 2012 study by Traore et al. indicates: in said study, the researchers analyzed the effects of heat treatments on meat from the M. longissimus thoracis from Galia and Redone pigs. What they found was a striking and statistically significant correlation between the presence and level of oxidized proteins and the drip loss during cooking / frying. This observation does not only suggesting a possibly reduced ability of oxidized proteins to retain water, but also the possibility of using the drip loss, which is a marker of meat quality, anyways, as an easily accessible indicator / estimate for protein oxidation.
  • Figure 3: Time matters, but heat, too - Markers of protein oxidation in meat exposed to 100°C (grey) and 270°C for the time in minutes indicated on the x-axes (Santé-Lhoutellier. 2008).
    In fact, previous research confirms and underli-nes the importance of time and tempera-ture and indicates that even at temperatures of only 100°C, the level of oxidation products in meat proteins will double within just 5 minutes.

    When the time of exposure is short, the corresponding +200% increase in carbonyls (a marker of PROTOX | see Figure 3) that occurs at low temperatures is allegedly relatively small. If you are into slow-cooking your meats at "low" temperatures for several minutes, any low temp. advantage would be lost, though.
  • Traditional processing methods to increase the storage time like dry-curing or fermentation - In contrast to the effects of heat treatment(s), the ones of other common processing methods are comparably under-researched. What we do know, however, is that dry-curing meats (and probably dry-aging, too - although a study on that has still to be done, to answer your Facebook question honestly, Matthew) can lead to sign. hydrolytic degradation of proteins (Toldrá, 1998). Furthermore, recent studies indicate that meat proteins will also undergo different, often more intense (compared to proteolysis) oxidative reactions during dry curing (Estévez. 2011).
    Figure 4: Carbonyl content (nmoles/mg protein) in longissimus dorsi (unprocessed) and dry-cured loins from different pigs on diefferent diets; % indicates relative increase in protein oxidation (Ventanas. 2006).
    Studies carried out by Ventanas et al. (2006 & 2007) prove the presence of significant amounts of protein carbonyls in dry-cured loins and hams  - a process of which the researchers study shows that it was, once again, linked to the lipid oxidative reactions that occur during curing. 
Steaming uses temps >60°C where proteins start to oxidize and steaming takes its time. It is thus not per se safe.
Steaming is not the solution: Unfortunately, detailed comparisons of the effects of steaming, microwave cooking, smoking, grilling, frying, and other cooking methods are not available - temperature level and duration of heat treatment have been the major focus in the literature and the results indicate that even "low" temperatures, such as the 100°C of steam will induce significant damage to meat, poultry or fish proteins during the 5-10 minutes they have to be exposed to the thermic treatment; that's because even at temperatures only slightly >60 °C can cause the oxidative cleavage of the porphyrin ring, which in turn will result in an increased release of heme iron, which has been shown to drive both, lipid and protein oxidation (Miller. 1994).
  • The hams, which are subjected to longer and more severe drying conditions, were found to have considerably larger amounts of protein carbonyls than the loins (≈ 9 nmol/mg protein vs. ≈ 1.3 nmol/mg protein). The manufacture of dry-cured meats involves a lengthy process (up to 36 months for Iberian dry-cured hams) and several operations such as salting, post-salting, drying and cellar (Ventanas. 2007). Little is known about the impact of each step on the onset and intensity of the oxidative reactions affecting to meat proteins. What studies have shown, however, is that ..
    "[s]alting, which is a common operation for the manufacture of numerous meat products, may have an impact on protein carbonylation. The addition of sodium chloride has an impact on the ionic strength of the environment which in turn, affects the degree of assembly of MP (Wick, 1999) their exposure to pro-oxidants and hence, their susceptibility to carbonylation (Montero, Giménez, Pérez-Mateos, & Gómez-Guillén, 2005). In addition, several authors have proposed that NaCl could enhance the activity of Fe3+ or that Cl− derived from NaCl would improve the solubility of such ion, hence, stimulating their pro-oxidant effects (Kanner et al., 1991 and Osinchak et al., 1992)" (Estévez. 2011).
    Accordingly, you can assume that the protein oxidation increases with the amount of salt that's used when meat or, as the study by Osinchak et al. shows, fish is cured - an interesting observation that should remind you of the link between high salt intakes and heart disease, of which said link suggests that it could at least partly be mediated by the effect of salt on protein oxidation in processed meats and other high protein foods.
  • Storage, cooling, freezing, high pressure and irradiation to reduce bacterial contamination, and packaging - You already know that cooked protein products have increased carbonyl levels compared to raw samples (1–3 nmol/mg protein in raw vs. 5 nmol/mg protein in cooked products), but the heat exposure is not the only threat to the proteins' integrity: cutting, mincing, and all the other processing steps protein foods undergo will likewise make significant contributions to the formation of protein carbonyls and other processes of protein oxidation.
    Figure 5: Evolution of protein oxidation in liver pâtés from Iberian and white pigs (note the difference that exists even before storage) under refrigerated storage (Estévez & Cava. 2004).
    In contrast to the former processing steps, the effects of subsequent refrigerated storage, has also been extensively studied - with disconcerting results, namely significant increases in the concentration and oxygenation of non-heme iron and thus the extent of lipid and protein oxidation (Estévez & Cava, 2004) which can render certain meat product, like liver pâtés that are refrigerated for several months quasi non-suitable for human consumption (see Figure 5) and will still significantly increase the protein oxidation of other less processed foods w/ lower amounts of iron such as chicken legs and breasts (see Figure 6)
    Figure 6: Changes in carbonyl content in chicken (a) leg meat and (b) breast meat as affected by freezing temperature and 6 months of storage at different freezing temperatures (Soyer. 2010).
    Now, freezing, which is particularly damaging if it is done at rather low temperatures at home (cf. Figure 6), is not the only storage method that increases the protein carbonyl content of meat and other high protein foods. In fact, storage per se will trigger natural biochemical processes that will inevitably favor protein oxidation. In that, decreases in pH and increases in the concentration of H+ ions are only one of various drivers of oxidative stress that can increase the susceptibility to protein carbonylation / oxidation - processes that will be further accelerated when meat is irradiated (common practice in the US meat industry) to kill bacteria (compare the size of the orange with the blue bars in Figure 7).
    Figure 7: Effect of Storage Time (12 Days) on Nonirradiated and Irradiated Raw Chicken Breast Meats Stored at 5 °C on Carbonyl Content as Lipid (in µmol Acetophenone/10 g Meat | Rababah. 2004)
    It is thus not surprising that Martinaud, et al. (1997) observed a significant increase of the carbonyl content in meat from beef longissimus lumborum and diaphragma pedialis muscles: from 3.1 to 5.1 nmol/mg protein and from 4.8 to 6.9 nmol/mg protein, respectively, during only 10 days of chill storage. Subsequent studies confirmed the occurrence of protein carbonylation during aging/chill storage of beef, pork, poultry, turkey, lamb, rhea, ostrich meat and eggs, in which Liu et al. (2009) found a 60% increase in egg white and a 41% increase in egg yolk protein oxidation.
Make no mistake: Eggs are healthy!.
Speaking of eggs, ... the change of the textural and structural quality of egg yolk and white upon heating is not the only change egg proteins will undergo while being heated at temperatures above 70 °C at atmospheric pressure or being exposed to high pressure of >500−600 MPa which will trigger the oxidative formation of disulfide bonds among the egg proteins (Van der Plancken. 2005 & 2006). That doesn't change my conclusion that the presence of oxysterols (oxidized cholesterol) is probably of greater health relevance than the lack of heat stability of egg proteins.
  • Due to the large variability of the data reported by different authors for the amount of protein carbonyls in similar meat samples analyzed, it is unfortunately not possible to infer general patterns (Estévez. 2011) - that's also because the "extent of protein carbonylation is highly dependent on the origin of the meat, type of muscle, species and the storage [and feeding] conditions" (Estévez. 2011).

    Another thing that appears to be proven is the fact that beef is significantly susceptible to protein carbonylation than pork - a fact scientists ascribe to the noticeably larger amounts of iron and myoglobin in cattle muscles (Lund. 2007a,b). Accordingly, it can hardly surprise you that a similarly lower propensity for protein oxidation has been found by Mercier et al. (1998) when they compared beef and turkey meat.
    Figure 8: Determinants of the susceptibility of meat(s) and poultry to protein oxidation.
    If the differences are in fact, as the scientists argue, due to the different amounts of iron and myoglobin in various muscle meats, it is not just logical that (a) beef is more susceptible to protein oxidation than pork, but also that (b) pork more prone to protein oxidation than poultry and that (c) gylcolytic, low fat, low myoglobin (strength) type muscle meat is less susceptible to carbonylation than oxidative, high fat, high myoglobin (endurance type) muscle meat (Filgueras et al., 2010) - how oxidized the protein in your meats is will thus depend on both, species and the cuts you choose (+ other previously discussed factors).
    Figure 9: Levels of AAS (a) and GGS (b) in dry-cured ham as analysed by LC–MS. Mean values correspond to area units from the peak integration of EIC for [M+H]+267 (AAS–ABA) and for [M+H]+253 (GGS–ABA) and corrected considering the total protein content of each batch. Different letters on the bars denote statistical differences (p < 0.05) amongst means. IF (intact format), CSF (conventional-sliced format) and ASF (alternative-sliced format - which also influence markers of protein oxid. | Fuentes. 2010).
    How significant the effects of other emerging processing technologies such as the application of hydrostatic pressure, which is used as an alternative to irradiation and pasteurization to kill bacteria, eventually is, has not yet been fully elucidates. While studies by Cava et al. (2009) and Fuentes et al. (2010) indicate that the application of high pressure can causes a significant increase on the amount of specific protein carbonyls, α-aminoadipic and γ-glutamic semialdehydes (AAS and GGS), "as a likely result of physico-chemical changes induced by hydrostatic pressure including tissue disruption and increase of free catalytic iron" (Estévez. 2011), the evidence is far from being conclusive and the pressure in your pressure cooker (~100 MPa or 15 psi) is 6 times lower than the 600 MPa used by Cava et al. (2009) and applied for a 100x shorter time periods than it took to produce significant protein oxidation in Cava et al. (2009) at 300 MPa. So the pressure in a pressure cooker is probably less of an issue than the time your meats and other protein sources will spend in it at high temperatures.

    The same goes for the commonly used modified atmosphere packaging (MAP), which has been shown to contribute to increased myosin cross-links, and increased protein carbonyls especially if the "modified atmosphere" is high in oxygen (70% to 80% | Lund 2007a,b) - a condition that has been shown to reduce the formation of thiol groups, i.e. fat oxidation, but has the obvious downside of increasing protein oxidation. Alternative packaging methods would be available, 100% nitrogen (results are mixed, e.g. Zanardi. 2002; Leygonie. 2011) or vacuum-packaging (effectively reduced protein oxidation during storage compared to MAP | Lagerstedt. 2011), for example, but just like the use of additives and ingredients with proven antioxidant capacity they are rarely used and more research is necessary to determine which of them offers the best protection to both proteins and fat.
  • None-meat, -poultry or -fish proteins react similarly - While there's lots of research on protein oxidation in meats, studies on other food sources are scarce, but show similar trends with respect to processing-induced protein oxidation.

    In cheeses, for example, the lowest amounts of protein oxidation are found in "unripe" raw milk cheeses or cheese that was produced from milk that was semi-cooked or pasteurized at low (vs. high as in UHT milk) temperatures (Fedele. 2001).
    Figure 10: Protein-bound carbonyls (PC) in selected cheeses from differently processed milk, i.e. unheated, semi-cooked and cooked milk as a raw ingredient (Fedele. 2001).
    With the processing temperature, the amount of protein-bound carbonyls (PC), the previously discussed marker of protein oxidation, increases, significantly. In Figure 10 illustrates that pretty well, after all, the cheeses that were made from cooked milk all have sign. higher PC levels than those from raw or semi-cooked milk. Much in contrast to meats, the storage or, in the case of cheeses, ripening processes does not trigger a continuous increase in protein oxidation (data not shown): For Grana Padano, a cheese that's produced from cooked milk, for example, the rapid (+30%) increase in protein carbonyls in the first 1-3 months of ripening does not continue and the level of PCs remains relatively stable for the rest of the several months period spanned by the study by Fedele et al.

    Figure 11: Kinetics of protein carbonyl generation by UV or fluorescent photooxidation. Protein carbonyls were determined in milk exposed to UV or fluorescent (FL) light, as a function of time of exposure to radiation. ■ = whole milk (WM) exposed to FL light; ● = skim milk (SM) exposed to FL light; □ = WM exposed to UV light; and ◯ = SM exposed to UV light (Scheidegger. 2010)
    Next to high temperature exposure (and yes, there will be some protein oxidation during pasteurization, but the process is fast enough to make the effects negligible | Table 1), UV radiation is a se-cond threat to dairy proteins.

    As the data in Figure 11 goes to show you, it takes only a few hours under a 15W UV lamp and/or a similarly "weak" fluorescent lamp to trigger rapid increases in protein oxidation in "milk", or rather what Scheidegger, et al. call milk, i.e. a liquid that was produced from water with commercially processed spray-dried whole milk powder, of which you can already expect that it has sign. higher baseline PC levels than regular milk.

    To deliver milk in regular, opaque tetra packs instead of the hipster glass bottles is thus a very good idea! Much in contrast to the use of regular or hypoallergic milk powders in processed and baby foods, the consumption of sweet condensed milk or its unsweetened alternative, evaporated milk.
    Table 1: Lysine damage in commercial milk samples (Mauron. 1990).
    Just like roller dried milk powder which is used in chocolates, and spray-dried lactose-hydrolized milk powder of which I have to admit that I don't know in which processed junkfoods it is used, the former food ingredients harbor significant amounts of blocked lysine, a previously discussed marker of protein oxidation that occurs relatively early during the oxidation process.

    Corresponding data for vegetable proteins is unfortunately not available. Even though vegetable proteins usually don't come with high amounts of easily oxidizable lysine (casein has a 2.0 ratio of lysine to arginine, soy's ratio is 0.9 | Kritchevsky. 1979), iron and myoglobin, soy, pea, hemp, bean and other vegan / vegetarian protein sources are not immune to processing, i.e. heat-, light-, and pressure-induced protein oxidation or the ongoing deterioration of their protein structure during storage. Whether these effects are strong enough to turn an originally antioxidant or neutral food protein into a pro-oxidant dietary ingredient, will yet need further clarification in realistic scenarios. Initial evidence that this could be the case comes from a 2015 study by Chen et al. who administered heat-oxidized soy protein to broiler chickens and observed that it would impair the chickens growth performance - probably as a result of negative effects on the digestive function. 
Don't be a fool: There's no evidence that protein powders are "adulterated" with exorbitant amounts of protein oxidation products; and, even more importantly, the currently available evidence in favor of the beneficial health effects of whey and co. clearly refute the practical health significance of the most likely existing amounts of protein oxidation products in the average protein powder.
Where's the info about whey, casein and other protein powders? In view of the fact that I can only report data that exists, it is very difficult for me to answer one of the most frequently asked questions I got after the publication of my original article on protein oxidation, namely: "What about my whey protein?"

What I have found out, though, is that whey proteins, like any other protein food, undergo heat-induced protein damage. For whey protein concentrates, Rector et al. report a rapid degradation of protein complexes when the protein is stored above the critical 60-65°C margin (Rector et al. used 80°C). Storage at 25°C for 1 year, on the other hand, resulted in polymerization of "only" 18% of the monomeric beta-lactoglobolins, and did not involve the formation of intermolecular cross-links, a characteristic feature of protein oxidation (Morr. 1993).

Whether the amount of protein oxidation products that certainly exist in casein, whey, soy, pea, and other protein powders is health-relevant, is therefore highly questionable. Furthermore, the well- and widely-established antioxidant effects of whey, which include, among other things, a reduction of protein oxidation in vivo (e.g. Haraguchi. 2011), would suggest that that the average whey protein doesn't just compensate, but over-compensate any potentially pro-oxidative effects of existing protein oxides by the anti-oxidant effects of its various antioxidant proteins and peptides (Tong. 2000; Peña‐Ramos. 2004; Peng. 2009).

In this context it may also be worth mentioning that a study by Fenaille et al. (2006), which investigated the protein-carbonyl (PC) levels in infant protein powder formulas, and is thus the study that comes closest to an analysis of PC levels in commercially available protein powders, found the amount of oxidized proteins to be not much different from those in unprocessed, cold-stored meat products. If certain quality standards during the production are met, it is thus unlikely that any potential worries you may have that protein powders could be much unhealthier than meat or other protein sources are warranted.
Wow, that was a lot of information on what you want to do or not do to reduce the oxidation of proteins. Since skipping on all protein containing foods and/or resorting only to raw meats, fish and milk is probably not an option. I have tried to use the previous information to phrase a few suggestions on what to do and not to do in order to limit your PROTOX exposure:
  • Figure 11: Influence of freeze–thaw cycles on TBARS (fat) & carnonyl (protein oxid.) in pork (Xia. 2009)
    buy, cook and eat fresh - it doesn't take heat to damage proteins, storage - even at very low temperatures - will also induce significant increases in protein oxidation; accordingly it makes sense to buy meat, poultry and fish fresh and to avoid storing and refrigerating them (esp. in view of the fact that storage / refrigeration in regular refrigerators will be more damaging than refrigeration of meats in much more efficient industrial refrigerators | Figure 11)
  • avoid irradiated and or high pressure treated, industrially processed meats and prefer vacuum packaged meats over meats in modified atmosphere packaging w/ extra high oxygen levels (nitrogen is no problem) - the less processed and messed up the meat you buy, the less significant any further increases in protein oxidation you may induce at home will be; you should also ask your butcher if he already froze and thawed the allegedly "fresh" meat he offers - you may not believe it, but much of the "fresh" meat has actually been refrigerated and thawed at least once - especially, the more exotic cuts; also, vacuum packaging your meats at home makes as much sense as any other way of repackaging it to keep them fresh - none of them is going to be worse than simply putting the meat into the fridge in nothing but a simple plastic bag; pressure cooking is, as discussed previously probably not an issue (due to the comparatively low pressure), but the time your meats and other protein sources spend in the pressure cooker at relatively high temperatures could be
  • use culinary herbs and spices - even though there is no data for each and every culinary herb and spice, the data that exists shows sign. reductions in protein, fatty acid oxidation and the formation of advanced glycation end-products (AGEs) for cloves, ground cinnamon, ground Jamaican allspice, apple pie spice, oregano, ground pumpkin pie spice, marjoram, sage, thyme, gourmet Italian tarragon, mint, rosemary, Italian poultry seasoning, turmeric, curry powder, chili powder, basil, nutmet, ginger, parsley, black pepper, and rosemary (Dearlove. 2008; Haak. 2008);
    Figure 12: Protein hydrazones (expressed as nmol hydrazones/mg protein) gain during refrigeration of cooked burger patties with added fruit extracts and quercetin (Ganhão. 2010).
    and using high polyphenol oils like virgin olive oil for cooking and in marinades may further reduce the protein oxidation; speaking of which, marinades and or fillings and the addition made from antioxidant-rich fruits or plant products (e.g. onions, garlic and other high quercitin foods that mimic the addition of pure quercitin in Ganhao (2010) | Fig. 12) have also been shown to help minimize protein oxidation not just during cooking, but also during storage
  • appreciate quality, non-cured meat - a high drip loss (meaning the weight of your meat is significantly reduce when you cook it) is a common marker of low meat quality and a correlate of high protein oxidation (Traore. 2012); the same goes for the loss of water that occurred way before you bought the meat during curing; and, yes, this means if there's a significant source of oxidized proteins in your diet, your beef jerky, bacon and other cured meats are the prime suspects - not only, but especially if they're also high in salt
  • choose low(er) fat meats, poultry, fish, dairy and vegetable protein over iron- and myoglobin-laden red meats - it's not just the lower iron and myoglobin content of poultry and fish that makes them more resilient to protein oxidation, it is also their low(er) fat content, which reduces potential cross-reactions of oxidized fats with proteins; this does not mean that you cannot eat fatty cuts of red meat, at all, but there's more than just epidemiological evidence that the consumption of high amounts of processed and/or improperly stored or packaged red meat is problematic; not just, but also because of high levels of oxidized proteins
  • Don't do everything the print on these packs tells you: While you certainly don't want to eat these silica packets, you also don't want to throw them away before you emptied your protein tub - they will help to keep your protein (and other supplements) dry!
    store your protein powders cool, dry, and by any means not in the sun - there's no evidence that protein powders could be a major source of oxidized proteins in your diet - unless you do your best to make them go rancid by (a) rehydrating and storing them as an RTD, which will significantly increase the amount of volatile compounds even if the product is cooled (Park. 2016 / storing the protein with or at least not removing the silica gel packets (see photo on the right) may also help), (b) storing your protein powders in transparent containers in the sun, or (c) putting your protein tubs right next to a radiator or any other heat source
  • prefer raw or pasteurized over ultra-high temperature processed (UHT) milk / dairy products - in contrast to what the scaremongering on the internet would suggest the short application of relatively low temperatures (72°C) during the pasteurization process does not induce significant damage to the protein-structure of dairy products; that's in contrast to UHT, which is done with at least 53°C higher temperatures and is notorious for its effects on the protein structure - an effect you will even taste and smell (Clare. 2005)
  • go easy on the heat and keep the duration of any heat exposure short - "well-done" or "tar-black" are words you shouldn't be forced to use to describe your dietary protein sources; you also don't want to simmer your meats and other high protein foods at 100°C (or even >65°C) for hours or fool yourself to believe that steaming your fish at 100°C for 10 minutes was so much better (in terms of protein oxidation) than frying it for 2 minutes
Figure 13: A comparison of the initial and progressing oxidation of myoglobin (data expressed as % of total myoglobin) in intact and minced slices of beef gluteus medius samples (3 mm thick) that were observed by Ledward & MacFarlane observed in their 1971 study clearly suggests that (a) the process of mincing induced protein oxidation and (b) makes the meat more susceptible to progressing protein oxidation during storage.
Any Facebook-questions left? Yes, the thing about gelatin. Well, I have to admit that I neither know why one would even remotely consider consuming gelatin in amounts that would make it worth worrying about its oxidized protein content, nor whether gelatine even contains oxidized protein. In view of the fact that EAAs like lysin appear to promote protein oxidation just like iron and myoglobin, and considering the fact that gelatin contains neither of them in sign. amounts, I do yet have my doubts that gelatin is a sign. source of PROTOX in your diet, Gillian.

And Kirill, reliable data on the protein-carbonyl content of ground vs. non-ground beef is not available. The increased surface (=more oxygen exposure = iron / hemoglobin oxidation) and the heat that is produced when you mince it, would suggest ground beef will have higher higher amounts of oxidized proteins. Evidence that this hypothesis is accurate comes from a 1971 study by Ledward & MacFarlane who observed higher levels of oxidized myoglobin in minced vs. intact beef (see Figure 13).

Now, before I leave you totally confused about your diet, let me add this: Neither this, nor the previous article I wrote about the health effects of protein oxidation should be misunderstood as anti-protein propaganda. Protein oxidation is, after all, only one out of a myriad factors that will determine the health effects of your diet. If you know about it and take the previously outlined measures to keep your intake of oxidized proteins in check, there's no good reason to assume that the occurrence of oxidized proteins in animal, vegetable or other protein sources would be reason enough to sign. limit their intake, let alone avoid them altogether | Comment!
References:
  • Chen, Nannan, Mouming Zhao, and Weizheng Sun. "Effect of protein oxidation on the in vitro digestibility of soy protein isolate." Food chemistry 141.3 (2013): 3224-3229.
  • Chen, X., et al. "Effects of heat-oxidized soy protein isolate on growth performance and digestive function of broiler chickens at early age." Asian-Australasian journal of animal sciences 28.4 (2015): 544.
  • Clare, D. A., et al. "Comparison of sensory, microbiological, and biochemical parameters of microwave versus indirect UHT fluid skim milk during storage." Journal of dairy science 88.12 (2005): 4172-4182.
  • Dearlove, Rebecca P., et al. "Inhibition of protein glycation by extracts of culinary herbs and spices." Journal of medicinal food 11.2 (2008): 275-281.
  • Estévez, Mario. "Protein carbonyls in meat systems: A review." Meat Science 89.3 (2011): 259-279.
  • Estévez, Mario, and Ramón Cava. "Lipid and protein oxidation, release of iron from heme molecule and colour deterioration during refrigerated storage of liver pâté." Meat Science 68.4 (2004): 551-558.
  • Fedele, E., and P. Bergamo. "Protein and lipid oxidative stresses during cheese manufacture." Journal of food science 66.7 (2001): 932-935.
  • Fenaille, Françis, et al. "Modifications of milk constituents during processing: A preliminary benchmarking study." International Dairy Journal 16.7 (2006): 728-739.
  • Filgueras, R. S., et al. "Colour, lipid and protein stability of Rhea americana meat during air-and vacuum-packaged storage: Influence of muscle on oxidative processes." Meat science 86.3 (2010): 665-673.
  • Ganhão, Rui, David Morcuende, and Mario Estévez. "Protein oxidation in emulsified cooked burger patties with added fruit extracts: Influence on colour and texture deterioration during chill storage." Meat science 85.3 (2010): 402-409.
  • Gatellier, Ph, et al. "Effect of cooking on protein oxidation in n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids enriched beef. Implication on nutritional quality." Meat science 85.4 (2010): 645-650.
  • Haak, Lindsey, et al. "Effect of dietary rosemary and α-tocopheryl acetate on the oxidative stability of raw and cooked pork following oxidized linseed oil administration." Meat Science 78.3 (2008): 239-247.
  • Han, J., and K. S. Rhee. "Antioxidant properties of selected Oriental non-culinary/nutraceutical herb extracts as evaluated in raw and cooked meat." Meat science 70.1 (2005): 25-33.
  • Kanner, Joseph, et al. "Lipid peroxidation of muscle food: the role of the cytosolic fraction." Journal of agricultural and food chemistry 39.2 (1991): 242-246.
  • Kritchevsky, David. "Vegetable protein and atherosclerosis." Journal of the American Oil Chemists’ Society 56.3 (1979): 135-140.
  • Lagerstedt, Åsa, Kerstin Lundström, and Gunilla Lindahl. "Influence of vacuum or high-oxygen modified atmosphere packaging on quality of beef M. longissimus dorsi steaks after different ageing times." Meat Science 87.2 (2011): 101-106.
  • Ledward, D. A., and J. J. Macfarlane. "Some observations on myoglobin and lipid oxidation in frozen beef." Journal of Food Science 36.7 (1971): 987-989.
  • Leygonie, C., T. J. Britz, and L. C. Hoffman. "Protein and lipid oxidative stability of fresh ostrich M. Iliofibularis packaged under different modified atmospheric packaging conditions." Food Chemistry 127.4 (2011): 1659-1667.
  • Liu, X. D., et al. "Effect of irradiation on foaming properties of egg white proteins." Poultry science 88.11 (2009): 2435-2441.
  • Lund, Marianne N., et al. "High-oxygen packaging atmosphere influences protein oxidation and tenderness of porcine longissimus dorsi during chill storage." Meat Science 77.3 (2007a): 295-303.
  • Lund, Marianne N., Marchen S. Hviid, and Leif H. Skibsted. "The combined effect of antioxidants and modified atmosphere packaging on protein and lipid oxidation in beef patties during chill storage." Meat Science 76.2 (2007b): 226-233.
  • Martinaud, Agnès, et al. "Comparison of oxidative processes on myofibrillar proteins from beef during maturation and by different model oxidation systems." Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 45.7 (1997): 2481-2487.
  • Mauron, Jean. "Influence of processing on protein quality." Journal of nutritional science and vitaminology 36.4-SupplementI (1990): S57-S69.
  • Mercier, Y., et al. "Effect of dietary fat and vitamin E on colour stability and on lipid and protein oxidation in turkey meat during storage." Meat Science 48.3 (1998): 301-318.
  • Miller, D. K., et al. "Dietary iron in swine rations affects nonheme iron and TBARS in pork skeletal muscles." Journal of food science 59.4 (1994): 747-750.
  • Montero, P., et al. "Oxidation stability of muscle with quercetin and rosemary during thermal and high-pressure gelation." Food Chemistry 93.1 (2005): 17-23.
  • Morr, C. V., and E. Y. W. Ha. "Whey protein concentrates and isolates: processing and functional properties." Critical Reviews in Food Science & Nutrition 33.6 (1993): 431-476.
  • Nieto, Gema, et al. "Thiol oxidation and protein cross-link formation during chill storage of pork patties added essential oil of oregano, rosemary, or garlic." Meat science 95.2 (2013): 177-184.
  • Osinchak, Joanne E., et al. "Effect of NaCl on catalysis of lipid oxidation by the soluble fraction of fish muscle." Free Radical Biology and Medicine 12.1 (1992): 35-41.
  • Peña‐Ramos, E. Aida, Youling L. Xiong, and Guillermo E. Arteaga. "Fractionation and characterisation for antioxidant activity of hydrolysed whey protein." Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 84.14 (2004): 1908-1918.
  • Peng, Xinyan, Youling L. Xiong, and Baohua Kong. "Antioxidant activity of peptide fractions from whey protein hydrolysates as measured by electron spin resonance." Food Chemistry 113.1 (2009): 196-201.
  • Rababah, Taha, et al. "Effect of electron beam irradiation and storage at 5 C on thiobarbituric acid reactive substances and carbonyl contents in chicken breast meat infused with antioxidants and selected plant extracts." Journal of agricultural and food chemistry 52.26 (2004): 8236-8241.
  • Rector, D., N. Matsudomi, and J. E. Kinsella. "Changes in Gelling Behavior of Whey Protein Isolate and β‐Lactoglobulin During Storage: Possible Mechanism (s)." Journal of food science 56.3 (1991): 782-788.
  • Rodriguez-Estrada, M. T., et al. "Effect of different cooking methods on some lipid and protein components of hamburgers." Meat science 45.3 (1997): 365-375.
  • Santé-Lhoutellier, Veronique, et al. "Effect of meat cooking on physicochemical state and in vitro digestibility of myofibrillar proteins." Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 56.4 (2008): 1488-1494.
  • Scheidegger, D., et al. "Protein oxidative changes in whole and skim milk after ultraviolet or fluorescent light exposure." Journal of dairy science 93.11 (2010): 5101-5109.
  • Smith, Mark A., et al. "Advanced Maillard reaction end products are associated with Alzheimer disease pathology." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 91.12 (1994): 5710-5714.
  • Somoza, Veronika. "Five years of research on health risks and benefits of Maillard reaction products: an update." Molecular nutrition & food research 49.7 (2005): 663-672.
  • Soyer, Ayla, et al. "Effects of freezing temperature and duration of frozen storage on lipid and protein oxidation in chicken meat." Food chemistry 120.4 (2010): 1025-1030.
  • Tessier, Frédéric J., and Ines Birlouez-Aragon. "Health effects of dietary Maillard reaction products: the results of ICARE and other studies." Amino acids 42.4 (2012): 1119-1131.
  • Tong, Lawrence M., et al. "Mechanisms of the antioxidant activity of a high molecular weight fraction of whey." Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 48.5 (2000): 1473-1478.
  • Traore, S., et al. "Effect of heat treatment on protein oxidation in pig meat." Meat science 91.1 (2012): 14-21.
  • Tuohy, Kieran M., et al. "Metabolism of Maillard reaction products by the human gut microbiota–implications for health." Molecular nutrition & food research 50.9 (2006): 847-857.
  • Van der Plancken, Iesel, Ann Van Loey, and Marc EG Hendrickx. "Changes in sulfhydryl content of egg white proteins due to heat and pressure treatment." Journal of agricultural and food chemistry 53.14 (2005): 5726-5733.
  • Van der Plancken, Iesel, Ann Van Loey, and Marc E. Hendrickx. "Effect of heat-treatment on the physico-chemical properties of egg white proteins: A kinetic study." Journal of Food Engineering 75.3 (2006): 316-326.
  • Ventanas, Sonia, et al. "Protein and lipid oxidation in Longissimus dorsi and dry cured loin from Iberian pigs as affected by crossbreeding and diet." Meat Science 72.4 (2006): 647-655.
  • Ventanas, S., et al. "Extensive feeding versus oleic acid and tocopherol enriched mixed diets for the production of Iberian dry-cured hams: Effect on chemical composition, oxidative status and sensory traits." Meat Science 77.2 (2007): 246-256.
  • Vuorela, Satu, et al. "Effect of plant phenolics on protein and lipid oxidation in cooked pork meat patties." Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 53.22 (2005): 8492-8497.
  • Wu, Wei, et al. "Oxidative modification of soy protein by peroxyl radicals." Food Chemistry 116.1 (2009): 295-301.
  • Xia, Xiufang, et al. "Physicochemical change and protein oxidation in porcine longissimus dorsi as influenced by different freeze–thaw cycles." Meat Science 83.2 (2009): 239-245.
  • Zanardi, E., et al. "Lipid and colour stability of Milano-type sausages: effect of packing conditions." Meat Science 61.1 (2002): 7-14.

Jumat, 06 Mei 2016

The Insulin / Glucagon Ratio and Why Diabetics and People W/ Severe Insulin Resistance Must be Careful With Protein

You're insulin resistant and trying to lose weight with high protein intakes? Then you got to read this article carefully...
High protein diets can help you lose weight while maintaining muscle mass. This should make them the ideal choice of diabetic patients, many of whom are suffering from weight issues that are often not corollary, but rather causatively involved in the development of type II diabetes.

Unfortunately, studies in type I diabetics and preliminary evidence from type II diabetics and other insulin resistant individuals suggests that - if the disease has progressed significantly - eating too much protein can be a problem, as well, one that may worsen the ill effects of diabetes.
Having high amounts of protein after fasting may ruin your glucose levels?!

Breakfast and Circadian Rhythm

Does Meal Timing Matter?

Habits Determine Effects of Fasting

Fasting Works - It Does, Right!?

Does the Break- Fast-Myth Break?

Breakfast? (Un?) Biased Review
The reason for the potentially detrimental effects of high protein intakes on glycemia is well-known, but rarely acknowledge: gluconeogensis. As early as in the 1970s, researchers observed that the administration of a high-protein diets to rats, can significantly elevate plasma glucose and insulin concentrations and reduce the sensitivity of fat cells to insulin (Blazquez. 1970).
Figure 1: Post-prandial insulin and glucose levels in rats after several weeks of high protein feeding (Blazquez. 1970).
Over the decades after the publication of the Blazquez study, evidence for both the beneficial (Tremblay. 2007) and potential ill effects (Unger. 1971; Eisenstein. 1974) of high protein diets on diabetes and insulin resistance has been accumulating (Linn. 2000).
Sign. increases in urea prod. are another consequence of protein-based gluconeogenesis (Gannon. 2001).
As usual you will find conflicting evidence: In 2001, for example, Gannon et al. found only a modest increase in serum glucose levels in type II diabetics in response to the ingestion of 50g of protein - in spite of the fact that ~20-23g of it were converted to glucose in the liver.

What is important to note, however, is the fact that the protein source in the Gannon study was lean beef - one of the slowest sources of protein you can have and thus not exactly the #1 candidate for being subjects to immediate and thus glucose raising gluconeogenesis.
In that, it has been know for almost as long that the degree of offset of the ratio of glucagon to insulin in type I and II diabetics may decide, whether the ingestion of high(er) protein diets will help or hinder glucose management. In the pertinent, seminal review, Unger observes that "the insulin:glucagon ratio (I/G) varies inversely with need for endogenous glucose production, being lowest in total starvation and highest during loading with exogenous carbohydrate" (Unger. 1971). It is thus not surprising that studies have observed that
  • the infusion of the glucose precursor, alanine, in the fasting state causes a fall in I/G, a “catabolic response,” but increases I/G during a glucose infusion, an ”anabolic response, which spares alanine from the fate of being abused for gluconeogenesis, 
  • similar effects have been observed after a protein load; normally after an overnight fast I/G rises in response to a beef meal, an anabolic response, while in the carbohydrate-deprived subject, the I/G does not rise, remaining at a catabolic level (cf. Chevalier. 2006)
Now, back in the day these observations were mainly used to support the concept of a "protein sparing action" of glucose. Today, the effect on gluconeogenesis, i.e. the production of glucose from proteins / amino acids in the liver, has moved to the center of attention of a number of scientists. Calbet and MacLean, for example, investigated how the plasma glucagon and insulin responses of humans would depend on the rate of appearance of amino acids after ingestion of very fast vs. fast protein sources.
Figure 2: Glucose and glucagon levels in the blood of healthy volunteers after ingesting either 25g glucose or protein solutions containing whey protein hydrolysate (WPH), pea peptide hydrolysate (PPH) or milk protein (MS | Calbet. 2002).
Their results (see Figure 2) indicate the obvious: Even in healthy individuals and even upon co-administering protein sparing and 25 g of anti-gluconeogenic glucose, the fastest protein sources (whey protein, WPI; pea peptide hydrolysate; PPH) produce the highest increase in glucagon, gluconeogenesis and thus serum glucose levels in the first 20 minutes after the ingestion of the 25 g of glucose plus ~30g of the different proteins.
Let's just be clear here: I am not saying that high protein diets cannot help with diabetes. I am just saying that bolus intakes of protein can be problematic for type I diabetics and people with severe insulin resistance and progressive type II diabetes.
What may not be a major problem for healthy individuals, though, can be a deal-breaker for diabetics, in whom studies into the inter-organ flux of substrates after a protein-rich meal (slow digesting beef 3g/kg body weight) show that the normally non-significant effect on glycemia (<5% in healthy subjects) was exuberant in the diabetic subjects in whom you will see a greater rise in blood glucose, and a three-to-fourfold increment in splanchnic glucose output at 30-90 min that was triggered by a doubling of arterial glucagon, which was not compensated for by an concomitant increase in insulin as it occurred in the healthy test subjects (Wahren. 1976).
Figure 3: Rel. changes in blood glucose after ingestion of 3g/kg lean meat in healthy and diabetic subjects (Wahren. 1976).
Whether an increase in protein intake will have beneficial or ill effects on your ability to control your glucose levels will thus clearly depend on the degree of hepatic insulin resistance / pancreatic dysfunction you expose.
  • If you are severely diabetic and/or insulin resistance, i.e. you either don't produce enough or no insulin in response to the ingestion of protein or your body does not react to the insulin, as it would be the case in type I diabetes and progressive type II diabetes, your glycemia may be impaired by high protein meals.
  • If you are only slightly insulin resistant, you will probably benefit from the insulinogenic effects of protein and the ability to replace carbohydrates in your meals with protein. You may nevertheless want to test your individual glucose response to fast-digesting proteins like whey or amino acid supplements, which may still result in an uncontrolled gluconeogenic response.
  • If you are healthy and insulin sensitive, you won't have to worry about the gluconeogenic effects of high protein intakes - regardless of whether we are talking about fast or slow protein sources, because the former will spike insulin enough to blunt any pro-gluconeogenic effects of the concomitant increase in glucagon to keep the rates of gluconeogenesis and thus your glucose levels in check.
So, just as you've read it here at the SuppVersity before, what's good and what's bad for your cannot be generalized - even when it comes to something as popular as increasing your protein intake.
What do you have to remember? High protein intakes, especially in form of large bolus intakes of 30g or more protein per session can trigger unwanted glucose excursions. These problems with glucose management occur almost exclusively in diabetics, in whom the protein-induced increase in insulin and / or the effects of this increase in insulin is / are blunted.

Figure 1: GIP and GLP-1 response to whey and white bread (left, top & bottom); insulin release (%) per islet relative to glucose after incubation with different amino acids, amino acid mixtures and mixture + GIP (Salehi. 2012) | more
Due to the unavoidable protein induced increase in glucagon, diabetics and people with severe insulin resistance will fall into a catabolic state in which the lions share of the protein they ingest will be subject to gluconeogenesis, i.e. the production of glucose from proteins / their amino acids in the liver. The consequence of the skyrocketing rates of gluco-neogenesis is an increase in blood glucose that will only exacerbate the existing damaging effects of elevated glucose levels in diabetics and people with severe insulin resistance. Since the of gluco-neogenesis depends on the rate of appearance of amino acids in the blood, fast-digesting proteins like whey are more prone to trigger this effect than slow-digesting proteins like meat.

If you don't belong to the previously referred to group of people suffering from type I or severe type II diabetes and/or severe insulin resistance, though, you don't have to worry that high(er) protein diets could mess with your ability to manage your glucose levels | Comment on Facebook!
References:
  • Blazquez, E., and C. Lopez Quijada. "The effect of a high-protein diet on plasma glucose concentration, insulin sensitivity and plasma insulin in rats." Journal of Endocrinology 46.4 (1970): 445-451.
  • Calbet, Jose AL, and Dave A. MacLean. "Plasma glucagon and insulin responses depend on the rate of appearance of amino acids after ingestion of different protein solutions in humans." The Journal of nutrition 132.8 (2002): 2174-2182.
  • Chevalier, Stéphanie, et al. "The greater contribution of gluconeogenesis to glucose production in obesity is related to increased whole-body protein catabolism." Diabetes 55.3 (2006): 675-681.
  • Eisenstein, Albert B., Inge Strack, and Alton Steiner. "Glucagon stimulation of hepatic gluconeogenesis in rats fed a high-protein, carbohydrate-free diet." Metabolism 23.1 (1974): 15-23.
  • Gannon, M. C., et al. "Effect of Protein Ingestion on the Glucose Appearance Rate in People with Type 2 Diabetes 1." The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism 86.3 (2001): 1040-1047.
  • Linn, T., et al. "Effect of long-term dietary protein intake on glucose metabolism in humans." Diabetologia 43.10 (2000): 1257-1265.
  • Tremblay, Frédéric, et al. "Role of dietary proteins and amino acids in the pathogenesis of insulin resistance." Annu. Rev. Nutr. 27 (2007): 293-310.
  • Unger, Roger H. "Glucagon and the insulin: glucagon ratio in diabetes and other catabolic illnesses." Diabetes 20.12 (1971): 834-838.
  • Wahren, J., P. H. I. P. Felig, and L. A. R. S. Hagenfeldt. "Effect of protein ingestion on splanchnic and leg metabolism in normal man and in patients with diabetes mellitus." Journal of Clinical Investigation 57.4 (1976): 987.

Rabu, 14 Oktober 2015

Non-Adherence and Design Problems: Two Reasons Why Recent Diet Study May Fail to Show Benefits of High(er) Protein + Dairy Intakes in Overfat (>37%) Women

Don't expect weight loss wonders from high(er) protein and dairy intakes, but especially when the energy intake is not controlled both can have benefits the study at hand could not detect.
What's better a calorie reduced diet with the suggested amount of protein or one with a slightly higher amount of protein and extra low-fat dairy in it, when it comes to shedding the exuberant body fat off the hips, abs and buttocks of 104 overweight / obese (or with a body fat content of 37%+ "overfat") premenopausal women?

That's probably not exactly the way the scientists from the Utah State University, the Pennsylvania State University, the University of Illinois and the FB Technical Center (Shlisky. 2015) would phrase their research question, but in the end, their 24-week three-phase randomized weight loss intervention comes tried to answer exactly this question.
Learn more about women's weight loss & co a the SuppVersity

1g PRO per 2g CHO + Circuit T. for Women?

Is the Optimal Exercise Order Sex-Specific?

1-3mg Melatonin Shed Fat W/Out Diet & Exercise

Not Bulky! Lifting Will Make Toned & Strong.

How to Really Train Like a Woman

Sex-Differences in Fat Oxidation - Reviewed
To learn more about the impact of higher protein intakes (30% vs. 20% of total energy intakes) and the purported "magic" of diets that are high in low fat dairy (in particular yogurt), Julie D. Shlisky and her colleagues had their subjects go through a three-phase weight loss intervention with
  • the JumpStart phase (weeks 0–2), being intended to kickstart the subjects' weight loss on a ~35% energy deficit, phase (2), 
  • the Weightloss phase (weeks 3–12; total of 12 weeks), during which the subjects were supposed to adhere to a 1,500-1,700kcal diet which came close to a 25-30% energy deficit compared to their baseline energy intakes, and
  • the Weightloss Maintenance phase, (weeks 13–24; total of 12 weeks), over the course of which the subjects had to stick to a dietitian designed "energy-balanced" diet which had still ~20% less energy than the subjects baseline diet (see Figure 4, right)
If you look at the tabular overview of what the subjects eat (I won't reprint 4 pages from the full text here) you can easily get confused and think that there were five different groups, eventually it does yet all come down to two groups, the intervention (INT) and comparison (COM) groups and their different diets during the previously explained phases of the study.
Figure 1: Macronutrient compositions of the prescribed diets in the intervention and comparison group (Shlisky. 2015).
In that, the most significant inter-group difference were (a) the macronutrient composition with 30% PRO, 25% FAT, 45% CHO in the intervention group (INT) and 16-17% PRO, 24-25% FAT, 59% CHO in the comparison group (COM).
Figure 2: Total intake (g) of carbohydrates, proteins and fats during the 12 week weight loss and maintenance phases (Shlisky. 2015)
"[w]eekly educational sessions were held for both INT and COM groups throughout the 6- month study and included lessons on basic nutrition knowledge, exchange patterns of eating, portion size and control, purchasing and preparing food and modifying recipes as well as motivational lessons on outcome expectations, selfregulation and monitoring, problem- solving, lifestyle modification, emotion eating and motivation for walking" (Shlisky. 2015) 
In addition, the subjects were told to consume 5 servings per day (with a focus on low fat yogurt) in the intervention and 3 servings of dairy (excluding yogurt) in the comparison group, as well as to finally get their behind off the couch for a total of ~8,000-10,000 steps per day (that was ~30-40 minutes of walking per day).
Thorpe et al. were able to show that high(er) protein intakes from dairy will decrease calcium loss and preserve bone mass (WB = whole body; LS = lumbar spine) while dieting. Don't fall for the "protein is bad for your bones" lie!
What does previous research tell us? If you look at previous research by Bowen (2004 & 2005), Josse (2011), Thorpe (2008) and Zemel (2004), there is significant evidence that high(er) protein intakes will augment fat loss and lean mass retention while increased dairy intakes may benefit bone mass and metabolic markers in men, women, young and old. In particular, when they are consumed alongside true exercise regimen, high(er) protein intakes have been proven have additive effects on body comp. during weight loss (8.8kg vs. 5.5kg fat loss in 16wks | Layman. 2005).

Against that background I would be very hesitant to take use the study at hand to argue that you can shed body fat just as effectively on the bogus "recommended diet" (=15-20% protein, 60% carbohydrates and 20-25% fat).
Needless to say that the novelty of the physical activity, of which I'd like to remind you that it had the same volume for both groups, must be taken into consideration when we take a look at the results of the 24-wk study:
Figure 3: Relative changes in markers of body composition after the weight loss and weight maintenance phase; all values expressed as percent difference to the respective pre-values in both groups (Shilsky. 2015).
Now, if you look at the overall effects and inter-group differences in Figure 3, three things are remarkable: Firstly, all subjects lost a significant amount of body weight and body fat without having to starve themselves or spending hours on the elliptical or treadmill. Secondly, there were no inter-group differences, which means that neither the overall increase in protein intake (see Figure 2), nor the increased intake of low-fat dairy and most prominently yogurt (effectively, the difference was only 1 serving per day, because the INT subjects failed to hit their target of five and ate only four servings per day) had beneficial effect on (a) the actual weight and more importantly fat / lean mass loss and (b) the subjects' general ability to keep the weight off during the follow up.
Figure 4: Reduction in energy expenditure (% of baseline) and total step count (activity level) of the subjects in the weight loss and weight maintenance phases of the study (Shlisky. 2015)
If we also take into account the data from Figure 3 which depicts the reduction in energy intake from baseline and the total number of steps participants in both groups took on a daily basis, we could yet conclude that the lower dairy (no yogurt) + lower protein group achieved very similar results with less efforts. There is thus no debating the scientists conclusion that
"[h]ealthy premenopausal women with excess adiposity effectively lost BW and fat mass and improved some metabolic risk factors following an ERD with approximately 20% protein and 3 svg/d of nonfat dairy intake." (Shlisky. 2015)
The increased protein or dairy (in this case mostly yogurt) intake did after all not offer significant benefits, as neither of the existing differences in Figure 3 was statistically significant.
The actual macronutrient ratio during the weight loss and maintenance phase (figure shows averages) was by no means what it was supposed to be. The women ate ~8% less protein than they were supposed to do.
So, there's no benefit to high(er) protein and dairy intakes? No, there isn't - at least in a study with such a questionable design. Did you recognize the culprit? Yes, you're right: What on earth do you expect to happen if you design a "weight maintenance phase" during which the subjects still have to consume an energy reduced diet... I mean, it is well possible that the dietitians equations said that the diet was "energy-balanced". If you compare their intake to the ad-libitum diets of the subjects (=their baseline diet), the women still consumed 18% (HP) and 27% (NP) less energy during the weight maintenance phase - this time with a significant inter-group difference in favor of the high(er) protein high(er) dairy (yogurt) group who consumed more energy during both the weight loss and maintenance phase with identical results.

I am not sure what you think, but I personally would refute any statement about the standard diet recommendation being as efficient as a high(er) protein + high(er) dairy variety based on the study at hand. The increased satiety effect, a potential increase in thermogenesis, etc. - all the purported benefits of high(er) protein intakes couldn't show due to (a) non-adherence (instead of 30%, the subjects in the intervention group consumed only 23% and 20% protein during the weight loss and maintenance phase, respectively, and were thus not far off of the 20% and 18% in the COM group) and (b) the stupid idea not to let the women eat an ad-libitum with a fixed macronutrient ratio during the weight maintenance phase. This is after all a more realistic scenario and one in which real benefits of high(er) protein can show | Comment on Facebook!
References:
  • Bowen, Jane, Manny Noakes, and Peter M. Clifton. "A high dairy protein, high-calcium diet minimizes bone turnover in overweight adults during weight loss." The Journal of nutrition 134.3 (2004): 568-573.
  • Bowen, J., M. Noakes, and P. M. Clifton. "Effect of calcium and dairy foods in high protein, energy-restricted diets on weight loss and metabolic parameters in overweight adults." International journal of obesity 29.8 (2005): 957-965.
  • In particularly in conjunction with exercise, high(er) protein intakes have been proven have additive beneficial effects on body composition during weight loss (Layman. 2005)
  • Josse, Andrea R., et al. "Increased consumption of dairy foods and protein during diet-and exercise-induced weight loss promotes fat mass loss and lean mass gain in overweight and obese premenopausal women." The Journal of nutrition 141.9 (2011): 1626-1634.
  • Shlisky, Julie D., et al. "An energy‐reduced dietary pattern, including moderate protein and increased nonfat dairy intake combined with walking promotes beneficial body composition and metabolic changes in women with excess adiposity: a randomized comparative trial." Food Science & Nutrition (2015).
  • Thorpe, Matthew P., et al. "A diet high in protein, dairy, and calcium attenuates bone loss over twelve months of weight loss and maintenance relative to a conventional high-carbohydrate diet in adults." The Journal of nutrition 138.6 (2008): 1096-1100.
  • Zemel, Michael B., et al. "Calcium and dairy acceleration of weight and fat loss during energy restriction in obese adults." Obesity research 12.4 (2004): 582-590.